Every box gets a fresh account and at least four weeks at the table, usually more, in Chrome and Firefox on ordinary laptops. We don't spend during the review, so the balance mark reflects the experience of someone who never pays. Shop pricing gets checked separately afterwards.
Depth. Are the decisions still interesting in week six, or is it timers all the way down?
How the game plays for someone who never pays, and how loudly the shop asks.
How soon a new account reaches its first real decision, and whether the middle keeps moving.
Interface, stability and load times in an ordinary browser over long sessions.
The score
The weighted total out of ten, printed on the spine. Nothing under 7.0 goes on the shelf: a box that scores lower stays in the cupboard rather than being shelved with a low number, because a shelf of things we don't recommend isn't useful to anyone.
Weight, players, time, ends
These are descriptions, not marks. Weight is complexity on the usual 1–5 scale: 1 is a family game, 5 wants a spreadsheet. Players is how many people share a world and whether they can hurt you. Time is a realistic daily visit. "Ends?" says whether the world resets. Use them to pick the box that suits the week you have.
Who pays for the cardboard
Affiliate commissions, and nothing else. "Open the box" buttons lead to each publisher's official site through a tracking link, and if you create an account afterwards the publisher may pay us. That doesn't change the price you pay, and it has never moved a score. Publishers don't see rulebooks before they're printed and can't buy a place on the shelf.
Re-sorting
The shelf is re-sorted every season. When a mark moves, the designer's notes say why and the date under the shelf changes.